Elite Prospects - Gretzky vs. Lemieux: A Timeless Debate of Hockey Greatness (2024)

Photo © Bildbyrån

Introduction

The debate over who is the greatest hockey player of all time has raged on for decades, and at the center of this discussion, two names consistently emerge: Wayne Gretzky vs Mario Lemieux. Both legends left an indelible mark on the sport, redefining what it meant to be a hockey superstar. In this article, we will compare and contrast the careers of Wayne Gretzky and Mario Lemieux, examining their remarkable statistics and the impact they had on the game.

Scoring Prowess

Wayne Gretzky, often referred to as "The Great One," is synonymous with scoring in the NHL. Gretzky's remarkable career spanned 20 seasons, during which he amassed a staggering 2,857 points (goals and assists combined). His ability to find the back of the net and set up his teammates is unrivaled, as he holds the record for most career assists (1,963) and points (2,857). Gretzky's incredible vision, hockey IQ, and playmaking skills set him apart.

On the other hand, Mario Lemieux, known as "Super Mario," had a career that was equally spectacular, albeit shorter due to health issues. Lemieux played 17 seasons in the NHL and amassed 1,723 points, ranking him seventh on the all-time points list. What makes Lemieux's career even more remarkable is his points per game (PPG) average. He averaged an astounding 1.883 points per game, which is the highest in NHL history, surpassing even Gretzky's 1.921 PPG.

Scoring Titles

Gretzky and Lemieux both dominated the NHL in terms of scoring titles. Wayne Gretzky led the league in points for a remarkable 10 seasons, while Lemieux led the league in six seasons. Gretzky's consistency in leading the league in points year after year is a testament to his unparalleled scoring ability and longevity.

However, when it comes to goals per game, Lemieux holds the edge. He led the league in goals per game on five occasions, showcasing his incredible goal-scoring prowess in the limited games he played due to injuries.

Championship Success

One area where Gretzky has a clear advantage is in championship success. Gretzky won four Stanley Cups with the Edmonton Oilers during the 1980s and added another with the Los Angeles Kings in 1993. His leadership and ability to elevate his game in the playoffs earned him the nickname "Mr. Playoff."

Lemieux, though undeniably talented, won two Stanley Cups with the Pittsburgh Penguins in 1991 and 1992. His impact on those championships cannot be overstated, as he won the Conn Smythe Trophy as the playoff MVP both times. Unfortunately, Lemieux's career was plagued by injuries, which limited his opportunities to chase more championships.

Legacy and Influence

Both Gretzky and Lemieux left an enduring legacy on the sport of hockey. Gretzky's records and accomplishments made him the face of the NHL for a generation. He popularized the game in the United States and helped it expand globally. Gretzky's influence on the next generation of hockey players is immeasurable.

Lemieux, while not as prolific in terms of records, is revered for his extraordinary skills and the inspiration he provided to countless young players. His ability to overcome health setbacks and still perform at an elite level is a testament to his determination and talent.

PLAYER	S	TEAM	LEAGUE	GP	G	A	TP	PIM	+/-		POST	GP	G	A	TP	PIM	+/-
AGE 19
Mario Lemieux	84-85	Pittsburgh Penguins	NHL	73	43	57	100	54	-33	|
Wayne Gretzky	80-81	Edmonton Oilers	NHL	80	55	109	164	28	41	|	Playoffs	9	7	14	21	4	10
AGE 20
Mario Lemieux	85-86	Pittsburgh Penguins	NHL	79	48	93	141	43	-8	|
Wayne Gretzky	81-82	Edmonton Oilers	NHL	80	92	120	212	26	80	|	Playoffs	5	5	7	12	8	-1
AGE 21
Mario Lemieux	86-87	Pittsburgh Penguins“A”	NHL	63	54	53	107	57	12	|
Wayne Gretzky	82-83	Edmonton Oilers	NHL	80	71	125	196	59	61	|	Playoffs	16	12	26	38	4	20
AGE 22
Mario Lemieux	87-88	Pittsburgh Penguins“C”	NHL	77	70	98	168	92	23	|
Wayne Gretzky	83-84	Edmonton Oilers“C”	NHL	74	87	118	205	39	78	|	Playoffs	19	13	22	35	12	18
AGE 23
Mario Lemieux	88-89	Pittsburgh Penguins“C”	NHL	76	85	114	199	100	41	|	Playoffs	11	12	7	19	16	-1
Wayne Gretzky	84-85	Edmonton Oilers“C”	NHL	80	73	135	208	52	100	|	Playoffs	18	17	30	47	4	27
AGE 24
Mario Lemieux	89-90	Pittsburgh Penguins“C”	NHL	59	45	78	123	78	-18	|
Wayne Gretzky	85-86	Edmonton Oilers“C”	NHL	80	52	163	215	46	71	|	Playoffs	10	8	11	19	2	-1
AGE 25
Mario Lemieux	90-91	Pittsburgh Penguins“C”	NHL	26	19	26	45	30	8	|	Playoffs	23	16	28	44	16	14
Wayne Gretzky	86-87	Edmonton Oilers“C”	NHL	79	62	121	183	28	69	|	Playoffs	21	5	29	34	6	10
AGE 26
Mario Lemieux	91-92	Pittsburgh Penguins“C”	NHL	64	44	87	131	94	27	|	Playoffs	15	16	18	34	2	6
Wayne Gretzky	87-88	Edmonton Oilers“C”	NHL	64	40	109	149	24	39	|	Playoffs	19	12	31	43	16	9
AGE 27
Mario Lemieux	92-93	Pittsburgh Penguins“C”	NHL	60	69	91	160	38	55	|	Playoffs	11	8	10	18	10	2
Wayne Gretzky	88-89	Los Angeles Kings“A”	NHL	78	54	114	168	26	15	|	Playoffs	11	5	17	22	0	-4
AGE 28
Mario Lemieux	93-94	Pittsburgh Penguins“C”	NHL	22	17	20	37	32	-2	|	Playoffs	6	4	3	7	2	-4
Wayne Gretzky	89-90	Los Angeles Kings“C”	NHL	73	40	102	142	42	8	|	Playoffs	7	3	7	10	0	-4
AGE 29
Wayne Gretzky	90-91	Los Angeles Kings“C”	NHL	78	41	122	163	16	30	|	Playoffs	12	4	11	15	2	0
AGE 30
Mario Lemieux	95-96	Pittsburgh Penguins“C”	NHL	70	69	92	161	54	10	|	Playoffs	18	11	16	27	33	3
Wayne Gretzky	91-92	Los Angeles Kings“C”	NHL	74	31	90	121	34	-12	|	Playoffs	6	2	5	7	2	-3

Conclusion

In the debate of Lemieux vs. Gretzky, there are no losers—only winners who had the privilege of witnessing two of the greatest hockey players of all time. Wayne Gretzky's incredible records and consistency in leading the league in scoring make him a compelling choice for the title of the greatest. On the other hand, Mario Lemieux's unparalleled points per game average and ability to dominate despite health challenges make a strong case for his greatness.

Ultimately, the choice between Gretzky and Lemieux comes down to personal preference, and perhaps, it's best to appreciate both for the unique brilliance they brought to the game of hockey. Whether you favor Gretzky's longevity and records or Lemieux's sheer dominance when he was on the ice, there's no denying that both players left an indelible mark on the history of the sport. Hockey fans will continue to debate Lemieux vs. Gretzky for generations to come, but one thing is certain: both players belong in the pantheon of hockey immortality.