Insurance Postcards/Insurance Direct Mail for Insurance Broker Advertising (2024)

We have worked with hundreds of insurance agents and insurance brokers, and we have tracked the data from all of those campaigns. Above you’ll find examples of the direct mail postcards our actual clients have used with spectacular results. You can use any insurance mailer template you see for your own business and customize it with your logo. Or, if you prefer, we can design you a brand new postcard from scratch. Simply use the arrows to scroll through the insurance mailers that work gallery, and don’t forget to further your marketing education with the amazing resources at the bottom of the page!

Contractors First Insurance, Inc., Calvin Butterworth

Samantha, Everything went just as you said that it would. Luke was great to work with. Thanks again, Calvin

State Farm Insurance, Carl Ross

Awesome place of business

Goodrich & Watson

114 potential new customers!

Nelson Construction & Renovations, Dominique Nelson

The postcard campaign with Postcard Mania was one of the best moves for our business we made this year. Not only was the service above and beyond what we expected, and the postcard design absolutely stunning, our business has absolutely exploded since sending them out. In fact, about four weeks after the postcards went out, our average number of website hits tripled, as you can see from the attached graph. Our Sales Manager has never seen as many leads as we have coming in right now. We know the successful action! More postcards!

Wise Home Insurance

5-10 responses per mailing, generating $250-$1,000, depending on the policy.

TLC Insurance Group

Had 120 people attend our dinner, and those leads eventually generated $30,000 for our business!

Access Health Insurance Companies, Lorraine Nellis

I LOVE IT!!! Clean and simple, exactly what I wanted!

RBC Insurance Services

Sent out 6,000 cards, 20 to 30 people responded, and about half of them turned into customers - generating about $10,000 in revenue!

Farmers Insurance, Scott Edwards

Looks good to go! Haley was great to work with!!

IGA Adventure Center, Nancy Hughes

We had great success with our first mailing and we are at almost full capacity!

Marc Alkes Insurance

The postcards got 8-10 responses per mailing, generating $3,000-$5,000!

Value Insurance

Got 12 responses right away from the postcards, generating $2,400 in immediate revenue!

Pinnacle Insurance

$6,000 a month in premiums!

Senior Benefits Insurance

We have enjoyed a great deal of success so far in our efforts with your company. Our response rate is running 3-4 times what I am told is the normal .5 – 1% response rate for similar mailings. This of course, is very good for our business and is providing a key component to our growth plans. We look forward to continuing this program and just wanted to say thanks!!

State Farm, Vicky Y. Chen

After distributing 3,500 door hangers, we got 15 new customers... a 2,701% return on investment!

Insurx1, Lisa Sawoya

PCM is one of the BEST company's I have ever worked with in my 30+ years of consultative selling. Every person I have worked with thus far has been professional, responsive, patient and a real pleasure.

BWO Insurance Group, LLC, David Matta

We chose PostcardMania because of the excellent product, service, and value.

Campbell Insurance Center, Mike Mensch

FYI - Your company's follow up is fantastic. I've received multiple emails, calls and a packet in the mail with sample post cards. I liked the email about the CEO the most. Please tell everyone they are doing a great job.

Farmers Insurance

I was "blown away" by the quality of the employees at PostcardMania. Everyone was so helpful and pleasant to work with. Susan Tibbs did a wonderful job of helping me set up my program. I have referred her out to other agents. The response absolutely shocked us. We wrote so much high quality business. It allowed us to exceed our year end numbers! I will be spending another $10,000 in September. Keep up the good work!

Tiferet Israel, Jennifer Williams

Just wanted to thank you for the great job on our postcards. They look wonderful!

Ltc Insurance Specialists, Richard Zappasodi

From my first call to PostcardMania, I have been pleasantly impressed (which unfortunately doesn’t happen often). You guys really cater to the client, and not just talk at them. I have never received so much attention from a vendor. It’s like I’m actually important to you! Everyone I have interacted with has been great; respectful, professional, intelligent, informative and on and on. No complaints what so ever.You guys are the Amazon of Postcards, and I am very excited about our future together.

Senior Resource Center

$4,000 in immediate revenue!

Freeman Insurance Agency, Joann Freeman

I am so impressed. You use just the right amount of marketing, not overkill. When I need more marketing services, I will be seeking out PostcardMania.

Prestige Landscape Designs, Brad Seitz

Happy holidays Darcy! We had a great year, and with the help of you, And PostcardMania, our cards really paid off. will probably be looking to update our cards sometime in spring, So look forward to working with you again.

Clarity Financial Insurance, William Moeller

Design of the postcard looks great. Will have to amend a comment on the results of the mailing once it gets delivered

GGC Group Corporation Insurance Division

I have viewed the proofs and it looks good. I am impressed with the work y'all did. Let's move forward to print.

Allstate Insurance, Tahlia Dorsey

Maggie, I have to tell you that your customer service skills are AMAZING!!! Of all of the companies I have contacted for our different projects, you are the only person who doesn't seem like their life is about to end. So thank you so much! I wish I could tell your supervisor and you get a raise, a promotion, something. Good luck!

Senior Horizon Insurance, Lloyd Banks

Thank you both Jennifer and Gabriella! You did a great job!

Prewett Insurance Group, Rusty Prewett

This company is the best. They're more than just a postcard company, they're a marketing company and do an incredible job providing value for their clients.

Seniorhealth Llc, David Bennett

My personal team at PostcardMania is FANTASTIC! Charlene and Alexus are proactive and always reliable. They follow up with me, not the other way around. PostcardMania makes my marketing easy.

Talbert Insurance, Larry Talbert

Used PostcardMania since 2008. After our first mailing, one of the first accounts we sold was over $150,000! The results on our campaigns have always been very successful. Our return on investment averages about 225%, and we always get at least one very large account each year. The campaigns have made us one of the largest professional liability providers in Georgia and Florida.

Farmers Insurance, John Stewart

I wasn't hitting my numbers the way I wanted and was looking for a way to close the gap. PostcardMania for us rocks. We love them. It all went seamless. The cards went out and the phone started ringing. I met my numbers!

Affiliated Inspectors, Marge

You guys are efficient! and nice to work with! and good at what you do!

Harvest Moon Insurance, Jennifer Hull-Morehead

I am more than satisfied with the website design. Jonny was very creative, and incorporated me into the decision making. I am very pleased with his professionalism, and ability to offer suggestions, and still be open to my ideas as well. I would recommend him, and utilize him in the future for other projects. Thank you, Jennifer.

Glass City Heating And Cooling

This campaign had tremendous immediate results -- within one week we had received 10-15 calls from their postcards! On average, every 5,000-card campaign brings in about $20,000 in business!

Right Plan For You, Llc, Bob Horowitz

Your service is second to none.

Florida Insurance Advocates, LLC, Scott ONeil

Charlene Ford is excellent. Her attention to detail is fantastic. Deb H is also very helpful whenever called upon. You are lucky to have such fine people in your organization.