Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (2024)

Your deck is exposed to some of the harshest conditions. From extreme cold and buckets of snow in the winter to extreme heat in the summer and plenty of rain in the spring and fall, your deck has to deal with it all. All that weathering can take a toll on the health and structure of any deck and leave it looking a little worse for wear.

Eventually, you’ll need to repair or replace your deck. Keep reading to learn the kinds of damage you should watch out for as well as when you can repair your deck — and when it might be time to upgrade to a more durable deck solution.

When to Repair Your Deck

Since every deck tends to take a beating, how can you tell when your deck is just getting older, or if it’s time for some serious repairs? Here are a few key signs that indicate it’s time to repair your deck:

Loose Boards

Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (1)

Any sign of your deck wiggling isn’t a good thing. Whether you’ve noticed a few floorboards are loose or the entire structure seems a little unstable, you’ll want to investigate the problem before you start to repair your deck. A few loose boards are easily repaired, but if your entire deck seems shaky, you’ll probably have to start thinking about a deck replacement.

Rotten Boards or Beams

Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (2)

Rotted wood is a surefire sign that it’s time for a bit of deck maintenance. You can check for rot easily with a screwdriver. Simply walk around the deck, tapping on potential trouble spots where maybe you’ve noticed a lot of water pooling. When the wood feels soft under the screwdriver, and your taps start to sound like mushy “thuds,” you’ve hit wood rot.

It’s possible that only a small section of your deck has rotted, in which case you can usually replace just the affected boards — as long as the rest of your deck is in good shape. If you notice structural and support beams rotting, you are probably looking at a bigger deck repair.

Shaky Railings

Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (3)

If your railings are shaky, you’ll need to repair your deck. While the railing isn’t a major structural component of your deck, it is a big safety feature, especially if you have kids or if your deck is on an elevation.

If you notice your railing wobbling, first check the rest of your deck to make sure there aren’t problems with rot or rust elsewhere. If not, you may be able to simply tighten a few screws and add a few fasteners. If the damage to your deck railing is more extensive, you might have to put in a brand-new railing.

Cracked Boards

Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (4)

It’s time to repair your deck when you notice the boards of your deck cracking and splitting. Not only are these splinters hard on the feet, but they’re a sign that your decking just isn’t holding up anymore.

This is part of the natural aging process with older wood decks. As temperatures and humidity levels change, the wood swells and contracts. As the wood ages and dries out, this tends to lead to cracks. You’ll also notice cracks if you haven’t stained or sealed your deck in a while.

A few cracked deck boards can certainly be replaced, but if you’re noticing cracking happening all over the surface of your deck, it’s probably time to think about repairs or even replacement.

Compromised Joists and Beams

Your deck’s joists and beams are its most important structural components. These are the boards that support your deck and make up the platform below the part of the deck that you walk on. They should look strong and sturdy, like this:

Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (5)

If you notice any of these rotting, or if your deck seems to have shifted slightly off these supports, you need to replace or repair your deck. When joists and beams are compromised, your deck is no longer safe. Since these posts make up the foundation and structure for your deck, you need these in shape before you can host any summer deck parties.

To fix joists and beams, you’ll need to remove the boards that make up the platform of your deck, which takes a long time, and if you’re hiring someone, a lot of manpower. Many homeowners choose to simply replace their deck if major structural components like these have been compromised because they can be so expensive to fix.

Rusted Nails and Hardware

Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (6)

Rusted nails and bolts are another sign that your deck is getting up there in years. The more rusted those nails and bolts become, the more dangerous your deck is. Since nails and bolts are what hold everything together, you really can’t have them weakened by rust.

If you notice any rust happening on your deck, it’s best to just replace the rusty hardware. The sooner you get them switched out, the fewer problems you’re likely to have.

When to Upgrade to Composite Decking

Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (7)

If you keep noticing problems with your wood deck and feel like you’re always working to repair, stain, or re-seal your deck, it may be time to replace your wood deck with a composite option from Trex®. While composite decking can be more costly than wood upfront, composite decking is the lowest maintenance deck material. No more warping or cracking, loose or rotten boards, and no more sanding and refinishing!

There are a few ways to replace your wood deck with composite decking:

  1. Replace the entire wood deck with a composite deck
  2. Replace just the deck surface (platform) with composite deck materials

Option 1: Replace Your Whole Wood Deck With Composite Decking

Let’s say your existing wood deck has just seen too many years. The joists and supports aren’t what they used to be, and the deck itself just doesn’t seem structurally sound. This is your best opportunity to get rid of that old, shaky wood deck and replace the entire thing with composite decking.

At this point, you’re not missing out on any leftover life from the old deck, and you’d probably have to replace the old deck entirely anyway. If you’ve been thinking about making the switch to composite decking, now is the best time to do it.

Option 2: Replace Your Deck Platform With Composite Decking

There are some situations where you may be able to replace just the platform of your deck with composite decking.

If the structure of your deck is in great shape, you can simply remove the top layer of wood boards and replace that with composite decking materials. This applies if the top of your deck seems to be splintering and cracking, but the structure underneath is very solid. The joists and beams are all in good shape, and you’re not noticing any wobbling or shaking.

This isn’t the best solution for every deck, so always consult with a composite decking installation professional before you start any composite decking project. But it can be a great way to reuse a strong deck support system (and possibly save a little money) while getting a brand-new, beautiful composite deck that’s sure to last for decades.

Get Replacement Decking Materials at Zeeland Lumber & Supply

If your deck has seen better days, don’t worry. Zeeland Lumber & Supply offers the very best materials in both pretreated lumber and composite decking, including Trex, to fix it right up! Stop into one of our locations or request a decking quote for more information about getting your deck back in shape as soon as possible.

Is It Time to Repair or Upgrade Your Deck? 6 Signs to Watch (2024)

FAQs

Is it better to repair or replace a deck? ›

If any of your boards have come loose, this needs to be fixed. If just one or two are loose, that may mean a repair is sufficient. However, if multiple boards are loose, it may be a better idea to do a full deck replacement. You'll also need to look at the quality of the boards.

How to know if deck boards are bad? ›

Deteriorating wood decking

Moisture, heat, and humidity can cause fungal growth, leaving wood discolored, and even flaky. Check all of the boards for visible signs of mildew, discoloration, and soft spots. Use the tip of a screwdriver to test for soft, spongy areas.

When to replace decking? ›

Visible damage such as cracking, warping and rot are the main things to look out for when deciding if an entire replacement subframe is needed for your decking. More aesthetic surface damage, such as splintering, scratching or discolouration, can be repaired.

Is replacing a deck a good investment? ›

If you plan to sell your home in the near future, a new deck could be a selling point, yielding a return on investment between 50% to 80% depending on market conditions at the time of listing it for sale.

How much should a deck cost to replace? ›

Deck replacement costs, typically range from $5,000 to $20,000, which includes the cost to build a deck, demolish the old one, and reassess the land for the new design. Overall price also depends on many factors, and just like for a deck repair, it depends on your deck's size, deck materials, and location.

What is the average lifespan of decking? ›

On average, timber decking lasts for between 15 and 30 years. With the right care and maintenance, your decking can last for decades come rain or shine. In this guide we'll talk you through how to clean decking, how to strip decking as well as how to protect your deck and what to do with weathered deck.

Can I put new boards over old deck boards? ›

By installing composite decking directly on top of your old timber decking boards you will save time and money as you do not have to pull up the old decking boards but we strongly advise against this. Composite decking requires adequate ventilation beneath the boards to help prevent buildup of moisture and mildew.

How long will untreated deck boards last? ›

A deck made of untreated wood can last anywhere from 10 to 30 years. Decks made of treated wood and composite materials can last as long as 50 years. Many composite decks come with a 20-year warranty – and often a lifetime guarantee.

When should I change my deck? ›

The Deck's Age

You can expect a wood deck to last 10 to15 years. If you purchased a home with a wood deck over 15 years ago and haven't replaced it, it may be time. Age is a sure sign that you should replace a deck. Another problem with older decks is that building codes change.

Does updating a deck increase home value? ›

Experts estimate that decks have an average return on investment (ROI) of 72%. This means that your deck will contribute to your resale value when it comes time to list your home.

How hard is it to redo a deck? ›

This is an easy DIY project that doesn't require a permit or, in most cases, rebuilding the deck's structure, because posts and joists aren't directly exposed to the elements and often outlast the decking. You'll save a lot of time and money by replacing only the worst deck boards instead of the whole deck.

How much is a deck worth for replacement? ›

The Average Cost of Deck Replacement

According to the 2023 Cost Vs. Value Report, the nationwide average cost for a deck replacement ranges between $19,248 and $23,340. Interestingly, this investment can increase your home's value, with an expected recoupment of about 39%.

Does redoing a deck increase home value? ›

Nationally, a new deck provides a 44% return on investment (ROI) in added property value. So if you invest $20,000 in a new deck, your property value may increase by $8,800 — 44% of $20,000.

How many years should a deck last? ›

Which material lasts longer? A deck made of untreated wood can last anywhere from 10 to 30 years. Decks made of treated wood and composite materials can last as long as 50 years. Many composite decks come with a 20-year warranty – and often a lifetime guarantee.

Can I just replace the boards on my deck? ›

Yes, it is possible to put new decking over the old one! Keeping the old structure and replacing only the surface boards helps the homeowner to save time and money, instead of building an entire new frame.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rubie Ullrich

Last Updated:

Views: 5826

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rubie Ullrich

Birthday: 1998-02-02

Address: 743 Stoltenberg Center, Genovevaville, NJ 59925-3119

Phone: +2202978377583

Job: Administration Engineer

Hobby: Surfing, Sailing, Listening to music, Web surfing, Kitesurfing, Geocaching, Backpacking

Introduction: My name is Rubie Ullrich, I am a enthusiastic, perfect, tender, vivacious, talented, famous, delightful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.