Pros and Cons of Debt Management Plans (2024)

Debt management plans are a way to pay off your balances by working with a nonprofit credit counseling agency. With this approach, you can pay off your debts in five years or less and get other help managing your money.However, debt management plans are not for everyone, and there are some downsides to consider, including limiting your ability to take out new credit.

Key Takeaways

  • Debt management plans allow you to pay off your debt in five years or less.
  • To start a debt management plan, you need to work with a nonprofit credit counseling agency.
  • There may be enrollment and maintenance fees to take part in a debt management plan.
  • Debt management plans are only for unsecured forms of debt, such as most credit cards.

What Is a Debt Management Plan?

When you enroll in a debt management plan, you’ll work with a nonprofit credit counseling agency. Your counselor will contact your creditors to gain their participation and may be able to get them to reduce your interest rates, lower your monthly payments, or waive their late fees. A counselor can also help you create a budget, reduce your expenses, and better manage your money.

Under a debt management plan, you’ll make just one monthly payment to the credit counseling agency rather than paying your creditors directly. The counseling agency will disburse the money to your creditors on your behalf, based on a payment schedule they set.

Debt management plans require consistent monthly payments. They usually take three to five years to complete, and you must agree not to use or take on any additional credit during that time. You will likely have to close the credit cards that are part of the plan. At the end of your debt management plan, your accounts will be completely paid off, and you’ll be debt free.

The Pros and Cons of Debt Management Plans

Pros

  • Become debt-free within five years: Under a debt management plan, you typically pay off all of your existing accounts within five years.
  • Simplify your payments: Instead of having multiple payments and due dates to remember, you’ll make just one payment to the credit counseling agency. Having only one payment can make it easier to manage your money.
  • Improve your credit score: As you start making payments under the debt management plan, you may gradually improve your credit score.

Cons

  • Lose access to credit cards: To ensure you don’t rack up additional debt, credit counseling agencies will require you to stop using or even close your existing credit cards.
  • No new lines of credit: While enrolled in a debt management plan, you typically cannot open any new lines of credit, such as an auto loan or a personal loan.
  • Creditors may not participate: Not all creditors will agree to participate in a debt management plan. Student loans and secured debt is often excluded.

3 Credit Counseling Agencies to Consider

There are many credit counseling agencies in operation. While there are typically enrollment and maintenance fees, some agencies will waive those fees in certain circ*mstances.

Below are three nonprofit credit counseling agencies that offer debt management plans:

Credit counseling agencyCosts
American Consumer Credit Counseling$39 enrollment fee; $7 monthly maintenance fee.
Consumer Credit Counseling Service (CCCS)$0–$50 enrollment fee. $0–$75 monthly maintenance fee (varies by location). Most services are free, but those with a charge may be waived (depending on hardship).
Navicore SolutionsUp to $60 enrollment fee, dependent on state of residence; $27 average monthly maintenance fee.

Be aware of scam artists that may pose as legitimate credit counselors. When evaluating potential agencies, make sure they are nonprofit organizations.

Check any credit agency that you’re considering using with your state attorney general and/or your state consumer protection agency. The United States Trustee Program also has a list of credit counseling agencies.

Alternatives to Debt Management Plans

While debt management plans can be effective tools for repaying your debt, they’re not always the best strategy. For example, secured debts and student loans aren’t eligible for debt management plans, and credit counseling agencies may cap how much debt you can have to participate.

As you consider if a debt management plan is right for you, consider these alternatives:

  1. Debt consolidation: With debt consolidation, you take out a loan and use it to pay off your older existing accounts. With fixed payments and a potentially lower interest rate, a debt consolidation loan can help you save money and accelerate your repayment.
  2. Debt settlement: Debt settlement is a risky strategy where you stop making payments and try to negotiate with your creditors for a smaller amount.
  3. Bankruptcy: If your debt is more than you can afford to pay off, then filing for bankruptcy can remove your obligation to repay all of it. However, bankruptcy will remain on your credit reports for seven or 10 years, depending on the type of bankruptcy. The negative impact to your credit report will make it difficult for you to borrow in the future.

If you aren’t sure which approach is best for your situation, contact a nonprofit credit counseling agency and talk with a counselor about your options.

What Is the Purpose of a Debt Management Plan?

With a debt management plan, you’ll make just one monthly payment to the credit counseling agency rather than paying your creditors directly. The counseling agency will disburse the money to your creditors on your behalf, based on a payment schedule they agree on together. Debt management plans require consistent monthly payments. They usually take three to five years to complete.

Can I Set Up a DMP Myself?

You can set up your debt management plan (DMP) yourself, but you then have to manage your own payments and administer it yourself. Some debt management companies charge for DMPs, but some charities provide this service for free.

Should I Include All Debts in a Debt Management Plan?

You can aim to include all debts in a debt management plan, but not all debt will qualify. Mortgages and other secured debts are not covered by a debt management plan, but in many cases it makes sense to include all of the debt that qualifies.

The Bottom Line

Debt management plans allow you to pay off your debt in five years or less. To start a debt management plan, you need to work with a nonprofit credit counseling agency.

There may be enrollment and maintenance fees to take part in a debt management plan, and debt management plans are only for unsecured forms of debt, such as most credit cards. However, they can help you simplify your debt repayments, and ultimately allow you to get out of debt more quickly.

Article Sources

Investopedia requires writers to use primary sources to support their work. These include white papers, government data, original reporting, and interviews with industry experts. We also reference original research from other reputable publishers where appropriate. You can learn more about the standards we follow in producing accurate, unbiased content in oureditorial policy.

  1. Federal Trade Commission. "How to Get Out of Debt."

  2. Navicore Solutions. "Debt Management."

  3. American Consumer Credit Counseling. "Debt Management Program Fees."

  4. Consumer Credit Counseling Services. "Financial Counseling Service Fees."

  5. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. "How Can I Tell a Credit Repair Scam From a Reputable Credit Counselor?"

  6. National Foundation for Credit Counseling. "Debt Management Plans."

  7. Federal Trade Commission: Consumer Advice. "How to Get Out of Debt."

Compare Personal Loan Rates with Our Partners at Fiona.com

Pros and Cons of Debt Management Plans (2024)

FAQs

Pros and Cons of Debt Management Plans? ›

If you're struggling to meet regular repayments, a debt management plan (DMP) can take some of the pressure off. But it can also make it hard to borrow money from lenders – this can affect your lifestyle and limit your options.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of a debt management plan? ›

If you're struggling to meet regular repayments, a debt management plan (DMP) can take some of the pressure off. But it can also make it hard to borrow money from lenders – this can affect your lifestyle and limit your options.

Are debt management programs a good idea? ›

Become debt-free within five years: Under a debt management plan, you typically pay off all of your existing accounts within five years. Simplify your payments: Instead of having multiple payments and due dates to remember, you'll make just one payment to the credit counseling agency.

Does a DMP hurt your credit? ›

The idea of having a notation on your credit history may initially send up red flags. But while a debt management plan does affect your credit history, it does not have a lasting negative effect on your credit score.

Is a DMP good or bad? ›

A DMP may be a good option if the following apply to you: you can afford your living costs and have a way to deal with any priority debts, but you're struggling to keep up with your credit cards and loans. you'd like someone to deal with your creditors for you. making one set monthly payment will help you to budget.

What is not a benefit of a DMP? ›

Negatively Impacts Your Credit Score

While a DMP isn't officially listed on your credit record like other formal insolvency procedures, it will still have a negative impact on your credit score. This is because you'll be making repayments at a slower rate than originally agreed upon.

Can I get a credit card while on a debt management plan? ›

Can you get a new credit card on a debt management plan? While on a debt management plan (DMP), you are technically free to take out a new credit card – though you may find it harder to be approved for one. When you apply for credit, lenders typically conduct a thorough check on your credit report.

What is a disadvantage of a debt management plan? ›

The cons of Debt Management Plans

Creditors require the accounts to be closed in order to be put on a DMP. This can slightly lower your credit score, because closing multiple accounts at the same time affects the length of your credit history.

What is the average interest rate on a debt management plan? ›

Every participating creditor offers their own rates, but in aggregate, the average interest rate for accounts included on a debt management plan with MMI is below 8%.

Do most creditors accept DMP? ›

Sometimes a creditor will refuse to deal with a DMP provider. This could be because the creditor doesn't want to accept the reduced payments or sometimes it could be because they've objected to you using a fee-charging provider, which would mean there's less money to pay the debts you have with them.

What happens if I pay off my DMP early? ›

You'll also want to notify your creditors of your decision so you can discuss the path forward. Pay off your debts. There's generally no penalty for making extra payments on your DMP, and if you can afford to pay off all of your balances at once, that'll end your agreement early. Stop making payments.

How long after a DMP can I get credit? ›

The accounts you are repaying your DMP through will already be listed on your credit report, and once the DMP is complete the marker will be removed and the accounts themselves will be marked as closed – they will then remain listed for six years from the settled date.

Can I keep my bank account on a DMP? ›

Your Bank Account & A Debt Management Plan

In conclusion, a Debt Management Plan (DMP) does not directly affect your bank account. You can usually continue using your current bank account as usual when you enter a DMP providing that you do not wish to include a debt on your DMP that is with your bank account provider.

How long can you be on a DMP? ›

How long does a DMP last? There is no set time for a debt management plan to last. It will simply go on for as long as it takes you to pay off your debts.

What debts Cannot be included in a DMP? ›

DMPs don't include priority debts. These are debts that have been secured against your home and other assets, as well as utility bills or Council Tax. You'll need to prioritise payments to these in your budget. These must be paid in accordance with the original agreement.

What happens if a creditor refuses a DMP? ›

My creditor will not accept my DMP payments

This means they may not accept the offer. Do not worry if this happens. This can be discouraging, but keep making payments. Your DMP payments are based on what you can afford after your priority bills and living costs are paid.

What are the consequences of a debt management plan? ›

Your DMP may show up on your credit reference file. Some creditors may ask for a note to be put on your file to say that you have a DMP. This would reduce your chances of getting credit if you applied for it while on your DMP, as it would show you've had trouble keeping up with repayments.

What happens when you enter a debt management plan? ›

You'll need to send your debt management plan provider a payment each month, usually by Direct Debit. The DMP provider will then pay your creditors on your behalf according to the terms of the plan. You don't have to worry about contacting your creditors to reduce your payments; this'll be done for you.

How long does a DMP stay on a file? ›

Instead, each debt in your DMP is marked as either 'AP' (arrangement to pay) or 'defaulted'. A debt with an AP marker stays on your credit report for six years from the date it is settled and a defaulted debt for six years from the first recorded default.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Fr. Dewey Fisher

Last Updated:

Views: 5714

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (42 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Fr. Dewey Fisher

Birthday: 1993-03-26

Address: 917 Hyun Views, Rogahnmouth, KY 91013-8827

Phone: +5938540192553

Job: Administration Developer

Hobby: Embroidery, Horseback riding, Juggling, Urban exploration, Skiing, Cycling, Handball

Introduction: My name is Fr. Dewey Fisher, I am a powerful, open, faithful, combative, spotless, faithful, fair person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.