Scalping vs Day Trading: Differences and Strategies - DTTW™ (2024)

Day trading is getting relatively popular globally. This growth is partly because of the Covid-19 pandemic that pushed more people at home. At the same time, the strong performance of the financial market was an incentive to many people about trading.

Companies like Robinhood, WeBull, and Schwab that offer free trading experience have also made it relatively attractive for people to trade.

Day tarding is not the only way to trade in the financial markets, and is often confused with swing trading or scalping trading. Which, as we see now, are very different approaches.

Contents

Trading approaches

Broadly, there are four main types of traders. First, there are those, who, like Warren Buffett, believe in buying and holding financial assets for months and years. These people are generally known as investors since they have a long-term horizon.

Second, there are swing traders, who have a medium-term horizon. These are people who buy and short assets and then hold them for just a few days. As the name suggests, they simply want to identify swings and then ride them for a while.

Third, there are people who have a relatively short time horizon. Day traders are those who believe in buying and holding financial assets for just a day. They don’t believe in holding an asset overnight.

Finally, there are scalpers, who believe in buying and selling financial assets within a few minutes.

Scalping vs Day Trading: Differences and Strategies - DTTW™ (1)

Day trading vs scalping: are they the same?

A common question among new traders is on whether day trading and scalping are the same. The answer is relatively easy to explain.

As mentioned, day trading is simply the process of buying and selling assets within a day. Therefore, since scalping does not involve holding trades overnight, it is a form of day trading.

A scalper, however, is much more active and makes many more trades during the day, because he focuses on achieving small but repeated gains.

Here are some tips to exponentially increase your knowledge of scalping technique.

» Related: To scalp or not to scalp?

Differences and similarities of day trading and scalping

There are several similarities between scalping and day trading. Let us look at the similarity first. First, the two approaches don’t believe in leaving trades open overnight. They believe that the overnight session presents substantial risks that can lead to significant losses.

Second, the two approaches can be applied in all types of assets, including stocks, currencies, bonds, and even exchange-traded funds.

Third, day trading and scalping require excellent money and risk management strategies to work. Some of the top risk management strategies to use are having a stop-loss, position sizing, and leverage.

There are also several differences.

First, scalping refers to a situation where a trader holds a financial asset for less than 5 minutes. In most cases, a scalper can hold a trade for even two minutes. Day traders, on the other hand, can hold trades for several hours.

Second, scalping requires opening tens or even hundreds of trades per day. This is simply because the overall profits per trade will be relatively low. Day traders, on the other hand, can open just a few trades per day.

Third, at times, day traders can rely on concepts like fundamental analysis. In scalping, this type of analysis is usually not necessary.

Scalping vs Day Trading: Differences and Strategies - DTTW™ (2)

Timeframes for scalping vs day trading

As mentioned, scalping is a form of day trading. Therefore, in this part, we will differentiate the two by looking at scalping vs day trading that involves relatively longer timelines.

In scalping, traders focus on relatively short timeframes. Most scalpers use as little short timeframes like about 2 minutes. In general, the average timeframe for most scalpers is less than 5 minutes.

Day traders, on the other hand, use relatively short timeframes. For example, they cannot use a four-hour chart because each bar in the chart represents four hours.

Therefore, since a day has 6 four-hour periods, it will not make sense to use such a period. Therefore, they too use relatively short timeframes, with the maximum being 30 minutes.

» Related: How to Find Better Trades With Multi-Timeframe Analysis

Day trading and scalping strategies

Different day traders and scalpers use various approaches to day trade and scalp. Let us look at some of the most popular strategies you can use when you are a day trader.

Momentum trading

This is a trading strategy that aims to profit in assets that are showing a strong momentum within a day. For example, if you see that a stock like AMC is surging in premarket trading, a scalper can buy it and get out when they make a small profit.

Similarly, if they see that a stock is making a strong bearish trend, they can short it and make a profit.

Using the VWAP

Second, there is a strategy that uses the VWAP indicator that we have looked at before. VWAP is the short form for the volume-weighted average price. Therefore, some traders buy stocks when they are above the VWAP and exit when they move below the VWAP.

Finding reversals

Another strategy you can use to both scalp and day trade is to find reversals. This is where you use several strategies and indicators to determine whether a reversal is about to take place. For example, you can look at patterns like head and shoulders and double-tops to determine when the reversal is about to happen.

You can also look at candlestick patterns like hammer and engulfing to determine when these reversals are about to happen. Also, you could use indicator reversals like MACD and moving averages to determine whether a reversal is about to happen.

Related »Which Chart Patterns Are Good for Scalping?

Finding continuations

The opposite of reversals is known as continuations. This is a process where you identify points of potential continuations. You can look at patterns like bullish and bearish pennants and flags and ascending and descending triangles.

Finding breakouts

The next key strategy in scalping is where you seek to find breakouts. You can trade breakouts using strategies like pending orders like buy stop and sell stop.

Summary: Scapling vs Day Trading, which is better?

Traders have preferences between scalping and day trading. In our experience, We have found day trading that involves longer timeframes to be a better trading option. This is because it does not involve opening of so many trades in a day.

External Useful Resources

  • Scalping vs Day Trading – What is the Difference – Fxssi
Scalping vs Day Trading: Differences and Strategies - DTTW™ (2024)

FAQs

Scalping vs Day Trading: Differences and Strategies - DTTW™? ›

Scalp trading involves making many trades in a single day to capture small price movements. It requires close market monitoring and high precision. Day trading refers to buying and selling financial instruments within the same day to capitalize on larger market trends.

Which is better scalping or day trading? ›

Because scalpers are looking to profit from small price movements, they typically have a high win rate but a low profit per trade. Day traders, on the other hand, are looking to capture larger price movements, which means they can afford to have a lower win rate as long as their profits per trade are larger.

Why brokers don t like scalping? ›

As I know, some forex brokers don't allow scalping because it involves super quick trades that can put a lot of stress on their systems. Scalping can also mess with their ability to manage risk since it's all about making lots of trades fast to grab small profits.

Is scalping the best trading strategy? ›

Those who are impatient and feel gratified by picking small successful trades are perfect for scalping. That said, scalping is not the best trading strategy for rookies; it involves fast decision-making, constant monitoring of positions, and frequent turnover. Still, there are a few tips that can help novice scalpers.

Is scalping harder than swing trading? ›

Scalping is for those who can handle stress, make quick decisions, and act accordingly. Your timeframe influences what trading style is best for you; scalpers make hundreds of trades per day and must stay glued to the markets, while swing traders make fewer trades and can check in less frequently.

How many trades do scalpers take per day? ›

Scalping requires the use of desktop trading software in order to execute the lightning-fast entries and exits required to capture small slivers or shavings of profit. Today, it's not uncommon for a scalp trader to execute over 100+ individual trades in 1 day.

Can you be rich in scalping? ›

It is theoretically possible to become a millionaire through scalping trading, but it is important to understand that this is a very difficult and risky way to try to achieve this goal. Scalping trading involves making multiple trades within a short period of time, often trying to profit from small movements in price.

Which type of trading is most profitable? ›

The defining feature of day trading is that traders do not hold positions overnight; instead, they seek to profit from short-term price movements occurring during the trading session.It can be considered one of the most profitable trading methods available to investors.

Is scalping riskier than day trading? ›

Scalpers are less likely to suffer margin calls and will risk fewer funds per trade. If you're looking to swing trade, you will probably require more funds in your account. Because you're more likely to stay in trades longer and you might need more margin to do this.

Why is scalping illegal? ›

. and why scalping laws? Well, it cuts down on ripoff artists buying large amounts of tickets to events and reselling them at inflated prices, or even selling counterfeit tickets.

Has anyone survived a scalping? ›

Although most frequently scalps were taken from victims who were dead or sure to die, events did occur where people who were scalped survived to reach medical treatment.

Why is scalping so difficult? ›

Scalping is very hard because we trade against other traders who are better equipped than us to operate in a noise market, where we have to act quickly, make many trades and this all requires constant focus, discipline and monitoring, it can be very tiring, is very easy to get off track.

How much money do day traders with $10000 accounts make per day on average? ›

With a $10,000 account, a good day might bring in a five percent gain, which is $500. However, day traders also need to consider fixed costs such as commissions charged by brokers. These commissions can eat into profits, and day traders need to earn enough to overcome these fees [2].

How are scalpers so fast? ›

Scalpers, using sophisticated bots that mimic human interactive behavior with a ticketing platform or website, rapidly purchase large quantities of tickets as soon as they become available. Hansen believes this practice gives scalpers a competitive edge over regular consumers and causes events to sell out quickly.

What is better than day trading? ›

Swing trade positions have a better potential for larger gains and losses than day trade positions since they are generally open longer. Because each trading approach is unique, traders should select a strategy that suits their talents, interests, and lifestyle.

Who makes more money scalpers or swing traders? ›

Swing traders will earn much more profit per trade – but you'll have to be patient, as you may not realize that profit for a few weeks in some cases. Scalpers, on the other hand, earn minuscule profit percentages per trade. After all, this strategy entails capitalizing on minor price movements over a few minutes.

What type of trading is most successful? ›

Conclusion. The most profitable form of trading varies based on individual preferences, risk tolerance, and market conditions. Day trading offers rapid profits but demands quick decision-making, while position trading requires patience for long-term gains.

Is scalping more profitable? ›

One of the main benefits of scalping is the potential for quick profits. Scalping is a strategy that aims to make small profits on a large number of trades. This means that traders can potentially make a significant amount of money in a short period of time.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Patricia Veum II

Last Updated:

Views: 6100

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Patricia Veum II

Birthday: 1994-12-16

Address: 2064 Little Summit, Goldieton, MS 97651-0862

Phone: +6873952696715

Job: Principal Officer

Hobby: Rafting, Cabaret, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Inline skating, Magic, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Patricia Veum II, I am a vast, combative, smiling, famous, inexpensive, zealous, sparkling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.