Return Profile
Risk and return are inextricably linked. Growth equity investing works to minimize risk while achieving venture-like returns. The return profile of growth equity can be best understood by comparing it to the venture capital and leveraged buyout private equity asset classes.
Venture Capital | Growth Equity | Leveraged Buyout | |
---|---|---|---|
Holding Period | 5 – 10 years. | 3 – 7 years | 2 – 5 years |
Target Internal Rate of Return (IRR) | 35 – 50 percent. | 30 – 40 percent. | 25 – 35 percent. |
Target Multiple of Capital Invested | 5 – 10x | 3 – 7x | 2 – 5x |
Source of Returns | Growth in revenue and fit between product and strategic buyer needs. | Revenue growth, profitability and strategic value. | Earnings growth and debt repayment. |
Exit Alternatives | Strategic buyer or IPO. | Strategic buyer, financial buyer or IPO. | Strategic buyer, financial buyer or IPO. |
Risk of Capital Loss | High | Moderate | Low |
Institutional investors who invest in private equity constantly evaluate the risk-adjusted return profile of their investment alternatives. The objective of institutional investors is to diversify but also to select investments that have an attractive risk-adjusted return. With the release of research analyzing growth equity returns, many institutional investors now consider growth equity to offer the most attractive risk-adjusted return profile in private equity. Whether this is a short-term phenomenon or a long-term trend is yet to be determined. However, there is no arguing that growth equity offers an attractive combination of downside protection and upside potential. After all, companies that receive growth equity are operating in established markets with proven products and are by definition growing. In a sufficiently large market, the upside potential of growth stage businesses can be significant and on par with venture capital, while featuring lower risk.
Risk Characteristics
Venture capital, growth equity and leveraged buyout investors all assume risk when they make an investment. However, the risks that each is willing to take vary greatly. By understanding which risks each type of investor is willing to take, entrepreneurs can better target their fundraising efforts to focus on the investors that are the best fit for the entrepreneur’s business. The table below describes the risks inherent in each type of private equity investment.
Venture Capital | Growth Equity | Leveraged Buyout | |
---|---|---|---|
Default Risk | No: Venture stage businesses do not typically have debt in their capital structure. | No: Growth stage businesses do not employ significant amounts of debt. As a result, credit default risk is not a primary feature of growth stage investing. | Yes: Financial engineering and use of debt are core features of leveraged buyout investing. |
Market Risk | Yes: Venture stage businesses often operate in new markets. | No: Growth stage businesses typically operate in emerging or mature markets. | No: Buyouts typically involve mature businesses operating in mature markets. |
Product Risk | Yes: Venture stage businesses often do not yet have a commercial grade product. | No: Growth stage businesses have developed a commercial grade product and often require capital to expand their offerings. | No: Mature businesses do not typically feature product risk. |
Execution Risk | Yes: Execution risk is unavoidable. | Yes: Execution risk is unavoidable. | Yes: Execution risk is unavoidable. |
Management Risk | Yes: The venture stage management team is typically an engineering- oriented founding team. | Yes: Growth stage businesses frequently go through periods of significant growth, requiring the addition of new corporate functions and management team members. Building a capable and well-functioning management team is a critical issue for growth stage businesses and a focus of growth equity investors. | Yes: Even mature businesses experience management change, although management risk in a mature business is typically less than is typical in venture and growth stage businesses. |
Risk of Capital Loss | High | Moderate | Low |
The primary risks undertaken by growth equity investors are execution and management risk. In contrast, venture capital investors often assume market and product risk in addition to execution and management risk, making venture capital the highest risk asset class within private equity. Conversely, leverage buyout investors typically undertake a lower level of execution and management risk than growth equity investors, but also accept credit default risk associated with financial leverage that is not typical for growth equity investments. Growth equity offers a modest level of risk , which can be mitigated by the value creation and team development tools that growth equity investors typically employ to support their portfolio companies.
Target Company Profile
Venture capital, growth equity and leveraged buyout investors invest at very different stages of a company’s life-cycle. Venture capitalists typically target early-stage businesses with little financial history. By contrast, leveraged buyout investors seek investments in companies that are financially mature, with a long track-record of revenue and profitability that can be analyzed. Growth equity investors make investments at an inflection point in a company’s history, where there may not yet be a long history of financial performance, but the core economics of the businesses are proven and can be evaluated. These core economics are referred to as unit economics.
Venture Capital | Growth Equity | Leveraged Buyout | |
---|---|---|---|
Revenue Scale | Pre-revenue to $3 million. | $3 – 50 million. | $20 million +. |
Unit Economics | Not determinable. | Proven, serving as the primary tool used to evaluate future earnings potential. | Proven, but traditional financial statement and cash flow analysis dominate the investment evaluation process. |
Profitability | Not profitable, monthly cash burn. | May or may not be profitable depending on level of reinvestment of profits into new customer acquisition. | Profitable, with a history of EBITDA and cash flow. |
Use of Proceeds | Product development, engineering, business development, sales and marketing. | Incremental investment in customer acquisition, product enhancement/extension, and operational scalability/support. | Purchase of equity from existing holders or purchase of assets. |
Control Features | Typically minority. | Minority or control. | Control. |
Ultimately, growth equity investors seek to invest in businesses that have established a repeatable and scalable customer acquisition process. When a customer acquisition process is repeatable and scalable, and the lifetime value of a new customer far exceeds the customer acquisition costs, growth equity investors gain confidence that incremental investment in customer acquisition will yield profitable revenue growth. In such cases, entrepreneurs and growth investors are well justified in partnering to accelerate a company’s growth.
Growth Equity Resources
- Cambridge Associates Report: Growth Equity is All Grown Up
- Association for Corporate Growth (ACG): Growth Equity, the Bright Spot in Private Equity
- Summit Partners White Paper: The Case for Growth Equity
- Workhorse Capital Growth Equity Blog:Are You Ready for Growth Equity?
- Wikipedia:Growth Capital