StudySmarter AI is coming soon!
- :00Days
- :00Hours
- :00Mins
- 00Seconds
A new era for learning is coming soon
Sign up for freeSelect your language
Suggested languages for you:
Americas
As a child, it is likely you were given sanctions for doing something bad, for example, failing an exam or breaking something expensive. You could have been grounded or had your TV privileges taken away for a while. The aim of this was most likely to teach you that there are consequences for your actions; but more importantly so that…
Content verified by subject matter experts
Free StudySmarter App with over 20 million students
Explore our app and discover over 50 million learning materials for free.
Criminal Punishment
- American Identity
- Ethnic Groups in America
- Gender Roles
- Race and Ethnicity
- Sex Education
- Sex and Sexuality
- Sexuality in America
- Beliefs in Society
- Age and Religion
- Contemporary Religion
- Economic Development and Religion
- Ethnicity and Religion Sociology
- Fundamentalism
- Gender and Religion
- Ideology
- New Age Movements
- Religious Movements
- Religious Organisation
- Science and Religion
- Secularisation UK
- Social Change And Religion
- Social Class and Religion
- Social Groups And Religion
- Society and Religion
- Sociological Theories of Religion
- Types of Religion
- Crime and Deviance
- Age and Crime
- Contemporary Crime
- Crime Prevention
- Crime and Society
- Criminal Justice System
- Criminal Punishment
- Data on Crime
- Ethnicity and Crime
- Functionalist Theories of Crime
- Gender and Crime
- Globalisation and Crime
- Green Crimes
- Interactionism Crime
- Marxist Theories of Crime
- Media and Crime
- Police Crime Statistics
- Social Class and Crime
- Social Distribution of Crime
- Sociological Theories of Crime
- State Crimes
- Victimisation
- Cultural Identity
- Concept of Culture
- Consumption Identity
- Ethnic Identity
- Gender Sociology
- Globalisation in Sociology
- Mass Culture
- Social Identity
- Socialisation
- Socialisation and Identity
- Theories of Socialisation
- Workplace Identity
- Education With Methods in Context
- Education System
- Educational Achievement
- Educational Equality
- Educational Policies
- Feminist Theory of Education
- Functionalist Theory of Education
- Government Education Policies
- Marketisation of Education
- Marxist Theory of Education
- New Right View on Education
- Privatisation of Education
- School Subcultures
- Teacher Student Relationships
- Families and Households
- Birth Rates
- Changing Patterns
- Changing Patterns of Divorce Sociology
- Child-Bearing
- Childhood As A Social Construct
- Children and Childhood
- Cultural Differences in Childhood
- Death Rates
- Demographic Trends UK
- Family Diversity
- Feminist Perspective on the Family
- Functionalist Perspectives on the Family
- LAT Relationships
- Lone Parenthood
- Marriage in Sociology
- Marxist Perspectives on the Family
- Migration and Globalisation Sociology
- New Right View of the Family
- Postmodernist Perspective on The Family
- Sociological Perspectives of Childhood
- Sociology of Personal Life
- The Ageing Population
- The Symmetrical Family
- Famous Sociologists
- Albert Cohen
- Ann Oakley
- Auguste Comte
- C. Wright Mills
- Charles Cooley
- Davis and Moore
- George H. Mead
- George Murdock
- Harriet Martineau
- Herbert Spencer
- Howard Becker
- Jeffrey Weeks
- Louis Althusser
- Michel Foucault
- Nancy Chodorow
- Pierre Bourdieu
- Robert K. Merton
- Stuart Hall
- Talcott Parsons
- Ulrich Beck
- W. E. B. Du Bois
- Global Development
- Aid
- Demographic Change
- Dependency Theory
- Environmental Impacts of Development
- Global Health and Development
- Global Inequality
- Global Organisations
- Globalisation and Employment
- Industrialisation
- International Development Theories
- International Organisations
- Modernisation Theory
- Non-governmental Organisations
- Post Development Theory
- The Developing World
- Trade
- Transnational Corporations
- Urbanisation
- War and Conflict
- Health
- Global Health Industry
- Inequalities in Healthcare
- Mental Illness as a Social Construct
- National Health Service
- Social Construction of Health and Illness
- Sociology of Mental Health
- The Social Determinants of Health
- Research Methods in Sociology
- Content Analysis in Sociology
- Data Analysis Sociology
- Ethics in Sociological Research
- Longitudinal Study Sociology
- Positivism and Interpretivism
- Primary Research
- Sampling in Sociology
- Secondary Research
- Social Institutions
- Access To Technology
- American Values
- Capitalism vs Socialism
- Conflict Theory Culture
- Construction of Social Reality
- Cultural Change
- Digital Age
- Economy as an Institution
- Forms of Government
- Global Education
- Government as an institution
- Issues With Technology
- Net Neutrality
- Online Privacy
- Poverty in the US
- Power and Authority
- Racial Politics
- Religion in US
- Social Change
- Social Movements
- Social Movements and Social Change
- Social Networking
- Symbolic Interactionism
- The Stages of The Family Life Cycle
- Theories of Aging
- Types of Societies
- Value of Education
- What is Society?
- World Religions
- Social Relationships
- Social Stratification
- Sociological Approach
- Classical Sociology Theorists
- Consensus vs Conflict Theory
- Education in UK
- Evaluation of Feminism
- Evaluation of Functionalism
- Evaluation of Marxism
- Karl Marx Sociology
- Key Sociological Concepts
- Max Weber Sociology
- What is Sociology
- Émile Durkheim Sociology
- Sociology of Education
- Education and the State
- Ethnicity and Education
- Formal and Informal Education
- Gender and Education
- Social Class and Education
- Sociology of Family
- Changes in Family Structures
- Conjugal Roles
- Contemporary Family Issues
- Families Around the World
- Family Types in the UK
- Stratification and Differentiation
- Age Discrimination
- Defining and Measuring Social Class
- Dimensions of Inequality
- Disability Discrimination
- Ethnic Inequality
- Gender Inequality
- Global Stratification
- Social Class Inequality
- Social Mobility
- Social Stratification Theories
- Socioeconomic Classification
- The Media
- Ethnic Stereotypes in Media
- Global Media
- Media Audiences
- Media Representations
- Media Representations and Audiences
- Media Sociology
- Media Theories
- New Media
- News Selection and Presentation
- Representation of Age in the Media
- Representation of Gender in the Media
- Representation of Social Class In The Media
- Theories and Methods
- American Sociological Association
- Case Studies
- Documents
- Ethnography
- Experiments
- Feminism
- Field Research
- Founders of Sociology
- Functionalism
- Interpretivism
- Interviews
- Longitudinal Studies
- Marxism
- Modernity
- Observation
- Official Statistics
- Positivism
- Postmodernism
- Questionnaire
- Research Considerations
- Research Design
- Social Action Theory
- Social Policy
- Sociological Imagination
- Sociological Research Methods
- Sociological Theories
- Sociology as a Science
- Sources of Data
- Types of Data
- Value Neutrality
- Values in Research
- What is the Study of Sociology?
- Work, Poverty and Welfare
- Causes of Poverty
- Consequences of Poverty
- Distribution of Wealth, Poverty, and Income in the UK
- Functionalist Theory of Labour
- Impact of Technology on Labour
- Labour Process
- Marxist Theory of Labour
- Poverty and Wealth
- Theoretical Approaches to Welfare Providers
- Types of Poverty
- Welfare Policy
- Work and Worklessness
TABLE OF CONTENTS :
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Lerne mit deinen Freunden und bleibe auf dem richtigen Kurs mit deinen persönlichen Lernstatistiken
Jetzt kostenlos anmelden
Nie wieder prokastinieren mit unseren Lernerinnerungen.
Jetzt kostenlos anmelden
As a child, it is likely you were given sanctions for doing something bad, for example, failing an exam or breaking something expensive. You could have been grounded or had your TV privileges taken away for a while. The aim of this was most likely to teach you that there are consequences for your actions; but more importantly so that you do things differently next time. This is a type of punishment.
In this explanation, we will:
- Define criminal punishment.
- Explore the purpose of criminal punishment.
- Look at the different types of criminal punishment.
- Learn how different sociological perspectives view criminal punishment.
Definition of criminal punishment
Criminal punishment works in a very similar way to the above example (with a few more complexities, of course). It refers to a method of controlling and/or reducing crime by punishing criminal offenders. It is complementary to crime prevention strategies but mainly focuses on dealing with the crime after the offence has been committed.
According to the Collins Dictionary (2022), we can define punishment as the following:
A penalty or sanction given for any crime or offence".
Criminal punishment refers to punishment in a lawful setting. Criminal punishment is a form of crime control that focuses on punishments for crimes, rather than prevention.
The purpose of criminal punishment
Criminal punishment exists as a form of social control. It aims to maintain order in society by providing a clear line between right and wrong. Laws are put in place by the government to help teach us what we can and can't do. Those who do not follow these rules, and break the law, are at risk of criminal punishment.
Some crimes come with larger punishments than others, whereas others may be broken and not prosecuted at all. Criminal punishment changes between countries and cultures, with different laws existing in different areas. However, the overall purpose of these laws and subsequent punishments is to keep order in society.
Let's explore the different types of criminal punishment.
Types of criminal punishment
Criminal punishment comprises several different approaches based on the desired outcome. This depends on whether the society or criminal justice system at hand aims to:
reduce occurrences of crime overall (reduction)
gain retribution for harm caused by a crime, or
restore justice to victims of a crime.
These are very common punishments for criminals. So let us look at each of these desired outcomes in turn.
Common punishments for criminals
There are several common types of criminal punishment: deterrence, reduction, rehabilitation, incapacitation, retribution and restoration.
Reduction of crime
Many societies aim to reduce the amount of crime being committed through criminal punishment. Reduction, rehabilitation and deterrence are all some of the most common strategic punishments for criminals.
Deterrence
This involves punishing the individual quite harshly to discourage them from future offending. Also, by making an example of them, significant punishments can act as a deterrent to other people who might consider committing the same crime.
If someone receives a big fine or a long prison sentence for a minor misdemeanour, this will ideally discourage others from doing the same to avoid the same penalty.
Rehabilitation
One of the primary purposes of punishment (for certain crimes) is to rehabilitate the criminal offender – ensuring that they undergo reform, change their ways and do not engage in the same criminal behaviour in the future. This gives them a second chance at an honest life.
Incapacitation
This is one of the most extreme methods of crime punishment focused on reduction and entails physically removing the capacity for the offender to re-offend in the same area. If they do not have the means or ability to commit the crime, they cannot do it.
Examples include long-term prison sentences, cutting off hands, chemical castration, or the death penalty.
Retribution of crime
This is based on the idea of 'an eye for an eye'; the concept of getting revenge for harm done. Many people in society, especially those who have been victims of violent crime, believe the criminal must pay for their crime for justice to be served. Since the criminal has caused harm, they deserve to have harm inflicted on them in return.
An example of retributive crime punishment is ascribing the death penalty for murder.
Fig. 1 - The death penalty still exists in most countries in the world.
Restoration of crime
Compensatory or restorative actions in crime punishment involve the offender making amends (or attempting to make amends) for the harm they have caused. This can mean paying a fine or providing some form of financial compensation to cover the cost of the damage they have caused.
It considers the wider concept of 'restorative justice', where the offender and the victim(s) of their crime are brought into communication. Restorative justice signifies a meeting between the individual responsible for the crime and the victim, sometimes with community representatives present. It is an opportunity for the offender to take responsibility for their actions and directly hear how they have impacted others.
For the victim, discussing or confronting the offender about the harm caused can help them better understand the situation and move towards healing and closure, if they choose.
Sociological theories of criminal punishment
Methods of criminal punishment usually involve restricting people’s rights and freedoms as well as sometimes inflicting harm on them. As a result, it can be quite controversial within sociology. There are many theories on criminal punishment, ranging from Durkheim's functionalist approach to Foucault's views about power. Different branches of the field have come to different conclusions on the nature and implications of crime punishment.
Functionalist view of crime
Émile Durkheim (1893), stated that the purpose of punishment for crime is to reinforce social regulation. Punishment is a way of upholding social solidarity by reasserting the shared norms and values of society; i.e. what is socially acceptable behaviour and what is not.
For example, a prison sentence for the committing of a certain crime reaffirms the boundaries of acceptable behaviour, not just for the offender but collectively.
Durkheim claimed that these rituals of order also act as means of expressing society's collective moral outrage. Durkheim thought criminals should be punished because punishments can morally unite members of society in their expressions concerning the crime, e.g. over how wrong the action is and why it should not be committed.
According to Durkheim, there are two types of societies - modern and traditional - as well as two corresponding forms of justice:
- Retributive justice: This is found in traditional societies. There is a strong sense of collective consciousness and solidarity based on similarities to one another. Punishment is severe and cruel and purely exists to express collective outrage.
- Restitutive justice: This form of justice is more commonly found in modern societies. There is an emphasis on individualism and solidarity is based on interdependence between individuals. Crime damages this relationship and the purpose of punishment is to repair the damage.
Fig. 2 - Different societies have different justice systems.
Marxist view of crime
Marxism, based on the ideas of Karl Marx, states that the purpose of criminal punishment is to maintain the existing social order. By protecting their property from the working class, punishment serves the interests of the ruling class by upholding the social class hierarchy. It is a repressive state apparatus - keeping the working class in their place by making them afraid to commit crimes, and therefore also discouraging them from rising up against the ruling class.
Marxists such as Rusche and Kirchheimer (1939) also argue that the type of punishment utilised by society depends on its economic structure. If the economy was not based on the exchange of money, for instance, the payment of fines would not be a punitive measure.
For Melossi and Pavarini (1981), under capitalism, imprisonment becomes the primary form of crime punishment because the prison system reflects capitalist relations of production. Time is crucial to workers in a capitalist economy as they are paid according to it and give up a significant proportion of it to earn a living. So, they 'pay' for crimes committed by having their time taken away in prison.
Foucault's view of power
In his seminal work on the birth of the prison, Michel Foucault ('Discipline and Punish', 1975) pointed out that criminal punishment has changed over time from being cruel, physically coercive and immediate (often involving torture and sometimes death) to focusing more on incarceration and rehabilitation of offenders.
However, while punishments have become less severe, they have ushered in an area of surveillance and control. He termed this a shift from sovereign power to disciplinary power.
- Sovereign power: This is the 'traditional' form of power. In pre-modern societies, this was where the ruling body, i.e. a monarch physically punished people's bodies for criminal activity through very dramatic public exercises of power.
- Disciplinary power: In modern times, punishment is not simply about the body but also the mind and is much more removed from the public eye. Foucault uses the example of the Panopticon - a prison designed so the warden/guards can see into the prison cells at all times, but the prisoners cannot see them, causing the prisoners to behave as if they are being watched even if they are not.
Foucault theorised that this disciplinary power has infiltrated other societal institutions so that workplaces and schools also function like Panopticon prisons, creating a culture of self-surveillance where people continually behave as if they are being monitored and change their behaviour accordingly. This makes it much more invasive as a means of social control.
Fig. 3 - The Panopticon prison is the embodiment of the surveillance state.
Criminal Punishment - Key takeaways
- Criminal punishment is when criminal acts are punished to reduce and/or control them.
- Approaches to criminal punishment include reduction, retribution, and restoration.
- Durkheim believes that its purpose is to reinforce shared social norms and express collective moral outrage. Traditional and modern societies have different versions of justice - retributive and restitutive.
- Marxist sociologists argue that criminal punishment upholds the social class order. Under a capitalist system, punishment mirrors exploitative relations of production by making workers 'pay' for their crimes in prison.
- Foucault theorised that the nature of punishment has changed from being strict and physical to more subtle and psychological, leading to a culture of self-surveillance. Sovereign power has changed to disciplinary power, e.g. the Panopticon.
References
- Collins Dictionary. (2022) https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/punishment
Frequently Asked Questions about Criminal Punishment
Criminal punishment refers to punishment in a lawful setting. Criminal punishment is a form of crime control that focuses on punishments for crimes, rather than prevention.
There are several main types of criminal punishment: deterrence, reduction, rehabilitation, incapacitation, retribution and restoration.
Criminal punishment exists as a form of social control. It aims to maintain order in society by providing a clear line between right and wrong. Laws are put in place by the government to help teach us what we can and can't do.
There are many theories on criminal punishment, ranging from Durkheim's functionalist approach to Foucault's views about power. Different branches of the field have come to different conclusions on the nature and implications of crime punishment.
Durkheim thought criminals should be punished because punishments can morally unite members of society in their expressions concerning the crime, e.g. over how wrong the action is and why it should not be committed.
Final Criminal Punishment Quiz
Criminal Punishment Quiz - Teste dein Wissen
Answer
Criminal punishment is a form of crime control that focuses on punishments for crimes, rather than prevention.
Show question
Question
What are the three main approaches to crime punishment?
Show answer
Answer
Reduction, retribution, and restoration.
Show question
Question
How is deterrence used in punishment?
Show answer
Answer
Deterrence uses harsh punishments to discourage both the current offender and future offenders from committing the crime.
Show question
Question
What is the purpose of rehabilitating criminal offenders?
Show answer
Answer
Giving them a second chance so they change their behaviours and attitudes and become less likely to engage in further criminal activity.
Show question
Question
Provide some examples of incapacitation.
Show answer
Answer
Long prison sentences.
Show question
Question
What is the concept of retribution based on?
Show answer
Answer
Getting revenge for the crime committed.
Show question
Question
Give some examples of restoration.
Show answer
Answer
Financially compensating the victim or organising a meeting between the offender and the victim to face consequences and encourage healing.
Show question
Question
What did Durkheim believe was the primary purpose of criminal punishment?
Show answer
Answer
To enforce social regulation and morally unite members of a society in their collective outrage at the crime.
Show question
Question
Define retributive and restitutive justice.
Show answer
Answer
Retributive justice is found in traditional societies with strong collective consciousness and is based on expressing outrage. Restitutive justice exists in modern societies with high degrees of individualism and focuses on repairing the harm done.
Show question
Question
Why do Marxist sociologists believe criminal punishment is a 'repressive state apparatus'?
Show answer
Answer
Because it protects ruling class property and discourages the working class from committing crimes or rebelling.
Show question
Question
What did Melossi and Pavarini (1981) say about imprisonment?
Show answer
Answer
It is the main form of criminal punishment under capitalism because it mimics capitalist relations of production by forcing offenders (workers) to give up their time.
Show question
Question
What are the two types of punitive power in society Foucault (1975) focused on?
Show answer
Answer
Sovereign power and disciplinary power.
Show question
Question
What did Foucault (1975) say about the Panopticon prison?
Show answer
Answer
It exemplifies the nature of punishment and disciplinary power in society overall - forcing people to constantly self-surveil and monitor their own behaviour.
Show question
Question
Define 'incapacitation'.
Show answer
Answer
Incapacitation is one of the most extreme methods of crime punishment focused on reduction and entails physically removing the capacity for the offender to re-offend in the same area.
Show question
Question
The purpose of rehabilitation is to make the criminal pay for their crime for justice to be served. True or false?
Show answer
Answer
False.
Show question
Question
Provide a definition of the criminal justice system.
Show answer
Answer
The Criminal Justice System (CJS) refers to a set of government institutions and systemswhose purpose is to apprehend, prosecute, punish, and rehabilitate criminal offenders.
Show question
Question
What do functionalist and subcultural theorists say about the CJS?
Show answer
Answer
Functionalist and subcultural theorists argue that the CJS exists to protect the public and enforce social values, punishing mainly male, working-class offenders.
Show question
Question
What is the philosophy of the CJS according to social action theorists?
Show answer
Answer
Social action theorists argue that the CJS scapegoats the working class for most crimes, ignoring other equally criminal sections of society.
Show question
Question
Describe what Marxist theorists argue about the CJS.
Show answer
Answer
Marxist theorists believe the CJS exists to serve theinterests of the ruling class at the expense of powerless groups in society i.e. working class and ethnic minority communities.
Show question
Question
What are the different agencies within the criminal justice system?
Show answer
Answer
- Police
- Crown Prosecution Service
- Courts
- Prison
- Probation systems
Show question
Question
What is the Crown Prosecution Service?
Show answer
Answer
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) decides whether a criminal case is likely to get a convictionin court. Prosecutorsadvise police, assess evidence, and prosecute the offender in court.
Show question
Question
What are the three strategies of crime reduction?
Show answer
Answer
Strategies of punishment that focus on crime reduction include deterrence, rehabilitation and incapacitation.
Show question
Question
Which of these is the definition of rehabilitation?
Show answer
Answer
When the offender undergoes reform, changes their ways and does not engage in the same criminal behaviour in the future.
Show question
Question
Give an example of restoration.
Show answer
Answer
Paying a fine or providing some form of financial compensation to cover the cost of the damage they have caused.
Show question
Question
According to Durkheim, punishment is a way of upholding ____ ____ by reasserting the shared ____ and ____ of society; i.e. what is socially acceptable behaviour and what is not.
Show answer
Answer
Social solidarity, norms, values.
Show question
Question
Who argued that the type of punishment utilised by society depends on its economic structure?
Show answer
Answer
Rusche and Kirchheimer (1939).
Show question
Question
Which of these institutions is NOT a part of the CJS?
Show answer
Answer
The police
Show question
Question
Which group of theorists argue that in targeting and arresting only particular groups, the CJS ignores other equally criminal subsections of society?
Show answer
Answer
Social action theorists
Show question
Question
The traditional Marxist view isthat the CJS reflects the interests of the ruling class and seeks to defend them - ____and____crimesare often ignored and the role of the police is to target those who are less powerful.
Show answer
Answer
Corporate, state.
Show question
Question
Provide an example of how Crown Prosecutors connect with the police force andadvise them in investigations.
Show answer
Answer
They can inform them of the type of evidence required to get a conviction.
Show question
Question
What is the difference between prison and probation?
Show answer
Answer
People who have been convicted of a crime are imprisoned, while the probation systemkeeps an eye on people even if they never officially went to prison or left it.
Show question
More about Criminal Punishment
60%
of the users don't pass the Criminal Punishment quiz! Will you pass the quiz?
Start Quiz
How would you like to learn this content?
Creating flashcards
Studying with content from your peer
Taking a short quiz
Sign up for free!
94% of StudySmarter users achieve better grades.
Sign up for free!
94% of StudySmarter users achieve better grades.
Sign up for free!
Discover the right content for your subjects
No need to cheat if you have everything you need to succeed! Packed into one app!
Study Plan
Be perfectly prepared on time with an individual plan.
Quizzes
Test your knowledge with gamified quizzes.
Flashcards
Create and find flashcards in record time.
Notes
Create beautiful notes faster than ever before.
Study Sets
Have all your study materials in one place.
Documents
Upload unlimited documents and save them online.
Study Analytics
Identify your study strength and weaknesses.
Weekly Goals
Set individual study goals and earn points reaching them.
Smart Reminders
Stop procrastinating with our study reminders.
Rewards
Earn points, unlock badges and level up while studying.
Magic Marker
Create flashcards in notes completely automatically.
Smart Formatting
Create the most beautiful study materials using our templates.
Sign up for free
Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.
GET STARTED FREE
This is still free to read, it's not a paywall.
You need to register to keep reading
StudySmarter is commited to creating, free, high quality explainations, opening education to all. By registering you get free access to our website and app (available on desktop AND mobile) which will help you to super-charge your learning process.
Register for FreeI'll do it later
This is still free to read, it's not a paywall.
StudySmarter is commited to creating, free, high quality explainations, opening education to all. By registering you get free access to our website and app (available on desktop AND mobile) which will help you to super-charge your learning process.
Register for FreeI'll do it later
Start learning with StudySmarter, the only learning app you need.
Sign up now for free
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.