‘Most expensive isn't necessarily best’: how to buy running shoes online (2024)

Although non-essential shops in England and Wales are allowed to reopen, some things remain easier to buy than others. Take running shoes, for instance: finding the right pair usually involves spending hours in store, picking up and trying on several pairs before moving over to the shop’s treadmill for a quick burst of running. Even with lockdown easing, this is not ideal. Buying a pair online is more convenient, but it can also feel like taking a stab in the dark.

However, that needn’t be the case. To take the fear out of buying running shoes online, here is an array of expert tips.

Do a gait analysis online

Gait analysis is usually the most tailored part of buying running shoes. It is how the retailer learns where on your foot you tend to land and how much your feet roll inwards upon impact. While it is tricky to do this online, it can be done. Steve Paterson, a product trainer at Runners Need, points out that the chain offers online gait analysis. “Shoppers simply provide us with videos of themselves running and answer a short questionnaire,” he says. “Run experts can help shoppers to find the right shoe, as well as providing advice on their running form, injury prevention and ways to get the most out of their running.” It is more of a palaver than in-store analysis, but it could stop you injuring yourself.

Do the squat test

The website Sporting Feet has a handy do-at-home test for prospective runners. Stand with your feet shoulder-width apart, then bend your legs. Where are your knees pointing? If they point in, you are likely to be an overpronator; if they point out, you might be an underpronator (also known as a supinator). If it is the former – as is the case for 70% of us – look for a shoe with built-in stability.

Check the returns policy

This is common sense, but still worth bearing in mind. Trevor Prior, the in-house podiatrist for the footwear and orthotics specialists Vionic, says: “Make sure you pick a brand with a good returns policy, as you will need to try on a range of shoes and opt for the one that feels the best.” Lots of brands have a 28-day policy, but beware the ones that don’t accept shoes that have been worn, especially outside.

‘Most expensive isn't necessarily best’: how to buy running shoes online (1)

Look for heel height

One often overlooked aspect of running shoes is the difference of sole thickness between heel and toe, especially if you are new to running. A higher heel-to-toe drop may reduce stress on your calf muscles and achilles tendons, so if you have tighter calves, perhaps due to a lack of experience, it is thought to be good to go for a higher drop. Prior says 8-10mm is a good start point: “This can reduce load to the calf muscle while you adapt, so taking time to find out the heel drop is worthwhile.”

‘Most expensive isn't necessarily best’: how to buy running shoes online (2)

Consider your distance

When you buy a pair of running shoes in a shop, you are likely to be asked what sort of running you will be doing. A pair of track shoes will be useless for a trail runner, for example, while someone who competes in marathons will need a different set of features from someone who wants to run 5km twice a week. Marthe Solberg, the technical representative for the running shoe brand On, says: “For longer distances, your body will take more impact from the ground and your muscles will work harder to absorb these impacts and utilise the energy for forward propulsion. Therefore, looking at more cushioned shoes may be beneficial.”

How experienced are you?

A mistake I made as a running newcomer was buying a pair of expert-level shoes that my body wasn’t prepared for. This happens a lot, says Solberg: “If you are a new runner and your body has not been conditioned to cope with the impacts from running, you might want to consider a more stable shoe.” She says “comfort plays an important role in preventing running-related injuries. In other words, runners may be less likely to get injured when wearing footwear that feels as comfortable and natural to them as possible.”

‘Most expensive isn't necessarily best’: how to buy running shoes online (3)

Pick the right size

Prior says most people buy shoes that are the incorrect size. If you are trying on pairs at home, he says, “there should be 1cm between the end of the longest toe and the shoe when standing. If the shoe is the right length and your foot is slipping when the laces are tied, then the volume or width of the shoe may be too big for your foot, so look at a different model.” Good laces also help more than you would imagine. “Remember, your foot will move forward in the shoe when running, so having adequate length and laces to hold your foot in position is important and may help you avoid blackened toenails,” Prior says.

Don’t equate price with suitability

As Paterson says, “the most expensive pair isn’t necessarily the right pair for you, so don’t be tempted into thinking that a higher price always equals a better shoe”. Instead, focus on the fit and feel, and the features most likely to help with the type of running you plan to do.

‘Most expensive isn't necessarily best’: how to buy running shoes online (2024)

FAQs

‘Most expensive isn't necessarily best’: how to buy running shoes online? ›

There is no correlation between price and performance. If that were the case, the most expensive trainers would be the best; that isn't true. Companies often use price as a marketing tool, and super shoes usually cost more because they are placed right at the top of the metaphorical food chain of brands' offerings.

Do I need to buy expensive running shoes? ›

There is no correlation between price and performance. If that were the case, the most expensive trainers would be the best; that isn't true. Companies often use price as a marketing tool, and super shoes usually cost more because they are placed right at the top of the metaphorical food chain of brands' offerings.

Is it okay to buy running shoes online? ›

Knowing Your Feet

Understanding your unique foot shape and size is crucial, especially when shopping for running shoes online. Ordering without this knowledge can lead to wasted time and money on returns. To avoid this, consider getting your feet scanned in-store and consulting a knowledgeable store clerk.

Is it cheaper to buy shoes online or in store? ›

Key Takeaways. Online shopping is often cheaper than in stores because online retailers may have fewer overhead costs. Online shopping also may come with the chance to apply more discount codes so you can save even more money. You may even be able to find cheaper gently or never used items on second-hand shopping sites ...

Should you size up or down in running shoes? ›

The further you run the more your foot will naturally expand. This means it's wise to have just a little extra room (about a thumb's width) between your longest toe and the front of the shoe. With this in mind, your running shoe should be around a half size larger than the shoe size you usually get.

What is the best brand for running shoes? ›

Our Top Picks:
  • ASICS GEL-Nimbus 26.
  • Brooks Ghost 15.
  • HOKA Clifton 9.
  • Karhu Ikoni 2.5.
  • New Balance Fresh Foam 1080 v13.
  • Mizuno Wave Rider 27.
  • On Cloudmonster 2.
  • Saucony Ride 17.
Apr 12, 2024

Is it better to buy running shoes a size bigger? ›

Christine Luff from verywell.com recommends going up half a shoe size because one's feet swell when they run and it is important to have plenty of room in the toebox. If one's toes are crammed in the front of the running shoe, you could develop blisters or black toenails.

How much do decent running shoes cost? ›

For the most part, shoes we review tend to be in the $100+ end as they are more well-built for higher mileage running. Most generic shoes under $100 lack a lot of comfort for racking up miles.

Is it okay to buy cheap running shoes? ›

When opting for a less expensive shoe, you may have to forgo a brand's top-tier midsole foam (the kind they put on their racing shoes), but that doesn't mean you'll be running on bricks just because you're paying less. Cheaper foam often returns less energy, but still provides a comfortable, well-cushioned ride.

Do expensive running shoes make a difference? ›

There's not much research about super shoes and injury, but many experts believe that while they might not necessarily increase injury risk compared with other types of shoes, they might shift the ways runners get hurt, Dr. Klein said.

How do I know if my running shoes are good? ›

Look for a shoe that flexes or rolls the way your foot wants to move—at the pace for which you'll be using the shoes. The midsole is foam material between the outsole and the upper, designed to cushion the runner from impact forces and guide the foot through the stride. Every runner will have their own preferences.

Where is the best place to buy shoes online? ›

The 15 Best Places to Buy Shoes Online and In Person
  • Best Overall Online: Zappos. Buy Online.
  • Best In Person: Nordstrom. ...
  • Best for Affordable Shoes: Old Navy. ...
  • Best for Dress Shoes: Reformation. ...
  • Best for Athletic Shoes: Foot Locker. ...
  • Best for Office Shoes: Vivaia. ...
  • Best for Trendy Styles: Asos. ...
  • Best for Outdoor Activities: Forsake.
Jan 2, 2024

Should I size up when buying shoes online? ›

Do not go for a pair that is one size up as it can cause problems with the fit. In the case of half-sized feet, you can consider buying a model that is half a size up.

Why are in-store prices higher than online? ›

Typically, online prices are lower to account for shipping costs and the cost of running a physical store is higher, so their prices are higher. If an online item is available at your local store, you can place a store pick-up order to receive the online price.

How do I choose the right shoes for my feet online? ›

7 tips for choosing the perfect shoes for your feet
  1. Choose a shoe with a firm foundation.
  2. Make sure it has arch support.
  3. Go for laces.
  4. Buy for your foot type and comfort level.
  5. Replace old, worn shoes.
  6. Get help when you have pain.

How do I know if my shoes fit online? ›

The most recommended way to get the fit correct would be to take your foot size and use the brand's specific sizing chart or guide to determine the best size for you. Measure your foot and use the brand's size chart to determine the correct shoe size (make sure to follow the instructions for how to check shoe size).

What should I look for in a running shoe for beginners? ›

The key factors are comfort, grip, cushioning, support, protection and durability. It's up to us to decide which of these factors we consider to be most important, so that we can then find the right shoe based on our chosen preference/s.

How do I know what running shoes fit? ›

When you're first trying on your running shoes in the store or at home, look for the following: Proper toe fit: You want a thumb's width of space between your toe and the end of the shoe. Midfoot and heel fit: You should have a snug (but not tight) fit at the midfoot and heel.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Lakeisha Bayer VM

Last Updated:

Views: 5580

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lakeisha Bayer VM

Birthday: 1997-10-17

Address: Suite 835 34136 Adrian Mountains, Floydton, UT 81036

Phone: +3571527672278

Job: Manufacturing Agent

Hobby: Skimboarding, Photography, Roller skating, Knife making, Paintball, Embroidery, Gunsmithing

Introduction: My name is Lakeisha Bayer VM, I am a brainy, kind, enchanting, healthy, lovely, clean, witty person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.