Revealed
lip service
Nathan Redmond responded to Pep Guardiola blast behind cupped hand and players whispering secretively has become a common sight in the Premier League - so why do they do it?
PEP GUARDIOLA'S bizarre rant at Nathan Redmond could land the Manchester City boss in trouble - but it also highlighted the latest trend to hit the Premier League.
Guardiola targeted the Southampton winger in animated fashion, questioning why a player of his ability had resorted to time wasting and negative tactics.
9
Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola has a massive go at Southampton star Nathan Redmond on full time
Redmond's response was to keep his cool despite the disappointment of a last minute defeat - and to give his reply behind cupped hand.
Footballers talking to each other while covering their mouths is becoming an increasingly common sight at matches nowadays.
And the belief has been that they do not want to give away important tactical information to their rivals on the pitch, or watching on TV.
It is happening so often there have been suggestions players are being briefed by experts not to get caught out saying something that could get them in trouble.
9
But in truth, the real reason they speak to each other that was has nothing to do with secrecy - it is all down to making sure they are being heard.
Renowned PR consultant Phil Hall, who has worked with some of the biggest clubs and names in the Premier League, says no-one is being advised to cover up to protect vital team plans.
RUDI HELL Antonio Rudiger reveals horror foot injury after stud goes through his boot
Hall said: "A player once told me one of the main reasons they do it is, sometimes you are doing it when you are close to somebody, it amplifies your voice so they can hear you.
"There is a lot of noise around them in a stadium and on the pitch, they need to amplify the voice.
9
"In a loud ground, when you speak normally the sound is being spread out.
"It's like a foghorn, if you put your hand over your mouth and point it to the person you are talking to it is much clearer."
Hall has worked closely with Manchester City, West Ham and Crystal Palace in recent years, as well as advising other high profile managers and players.
And though TV stations have looked into lip reading managers and players in other countries, he says it is not common in the UK.
9
9
He added:"It started in South America where a couple of TV stations hired guests to start reading what was being said on the benches and what was being said by the players.
"They employed lip readers and various methods to find out what was being said tactically by the bench to the players.
"But the players themselves over here, I think are just aping what they see on the continent. I don't think over here they are being actively advised to cover up.
9
9
"I have certainly not seen any evidence of lip reading over here, at any of the clubs I have done work with.
"When Roy Hodgson went to the World Cup, a lip reader announced she was going to interpret everything he was saying on the bench and publish it on a blog - so you can see why they are getting more and more cautious.
9
"But I don't think they have been briefed.
"I have not heard anybody saying anything about anybody being lip-read. I've never been asked to advise on anything like that.
"In NFL there is a whole pattern of tactics and play calls that can be read by a lip reader, but in football the game is just not that structured where it could potentially make a difference."
Watch all the Premier League action in our Wednesday night round-up
The article you've shared touches on several concepts related to communication and tactics in football, particularly regarding the behavior of players covering their mouths while talking on the field. As someone deeply involved in sports analysis and communication strategies within football, I can provide insights into these elements.
Firstly, Pep Guardiola's confrontation with Nathan Redmond sheds light on a prevalent trend: players communicating behind cupped hands. This behavior is increasingly common and often misconstrued as an attempt to maintain secrecy about tactics or strategies. However, the truth, as highlighted by Phil Hall, a renowned PR consultant who has worked extensively with Premier League clubs, differs from this perception.
Hall mentions that players covering their mouths isn't primarily about concealing tactical information from rivals. Instead, it's a means to ensure effective communication amidst the chaos of a football match. In a loud stadium environment with constant noise and distractions, covering one's mouth while speaking allows for better audibility. The action of cupping hands focuses the sound directly toward the intended recipient, amplifying the voice and ensuring clearer communication.
Moreover, Hall dismisses the notion that this behavior stems from coaching or PR advice aimed at concealing strategic details. He emphasizes that while lip reading might be prevalent in other countries, particularly in South America where TV stations employ lip readers to interpret tactical discussions, it's not a common practice in the UK. The adoption of this behavior among UK players is seen more as an emulation of trends observed elsewhere rather than a deliberate attempt to thwart tactical espionage.
He clarifies that football, unlike the NFL, lacks the structured, predefined plays and calls that could significantly benefit from lip reading. Hence, the motivation behind players covering their mouths lies more in enhancing direct communication rather than preventing strategic information leaks.
Overall, the behavior of players covering their mouths during conversations on the field serves the primary purpose of ensuring clear and audible communication amidst the noise and chaos of a football match rather than clandestinely guarding tactical secrets.
